Landlord Wrecks Occupied Home, Pleads Guilty to Misdemeanor

An Idaho landlord who used a tractor to tear into a home he owned -- while a family of renters with ties to political extremists was inside -- has pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor in the case.

Paul Fagerlie Finman pleaded guilty to disturbing the peace for using tractor-lift tongs to break into the home that he owns while a woman and her children were inside of it, The Bonner County Daily Bee reports. No one was injured in the 2010 incident, but the family, which was in the process of being evicted by him, told authorities that the experience was terrifying.

Finman, who originally faced three counts of felony assault, claimed that the family told him that they would move out of the rental by Sept. 30, 2010, according to The Herald Times Reporter. The landlord has been trying to tear down the house for 18 months, and the process has led to "substantial stress in his life," Finman's attorney, Jeremy Featherston, told The Bonner County Daily Bee.

But Bonner County chief deputy prosecutor Shane Greenbank told AOL Real Estate that there is "zero" evidence that Finman had told the family that he intended to demolish the rental home before he drove his tractor into it. Leading up to the incident, Greenbank said, Alexander Duncan Campbell, a resident of the home who is reportedly a member of a right-wing extremist group, had been trying to negotiate rent with Finman. But Finman, who had recently acquired the property that the house sat on, "wasn't cooperative," and wanted the family evicted, Greenbank said.

"He decided that driving the tractor through the house was a quicker process," Greenbank said, adding that Finman pursued the family with his tractor after they fled the home.

Finman was sentenced to 180 days in jail and must pay more than $400 in fines and court costs. But 178 days of his sentence was suspended and he received credit for two days he'd already spent in jail.

With a glut of foreclosed homes sitting vacant on a depressed housing market, bizarre incidents stemming from unwanted occupations have seemed to proliferate. In one of the strangest cases, authorities recently discovered two alleged squatters with 10 hand grenades, drugs, a firearm and a pig.

No barnyard animals or weapons were apparently at the center of this case, which was not a foreclosed home. But Campbell is reportedly a member of the Sovereign Citizen Movement which, according to the FBI, is a group of "anti-government extremists" who reject institutions including "courts, taxing entities, motor vehicle departments, or law enforcement."

Campbell's hard-line beliefs reportedly led him to forbid his wife and children from testifying against Finman. The landlord told the Hagadone News Network that eviction proceedings began after he received a death threat from Campbell that was couched in Biblical rhetoric.

Greenbank said that the family members were "necessary witnesses" for him to proceed with felony charges. "We were in a position where we could not serve the victims in the case," he said, since Campbell refused to allow his family to testify unless the prosecutor made warrants out for Campbell's arrest "go away."

Campbell is reportedly wanted by the Idaho counties of Kootenai and Nez Perce for offenses that include illegal possession of a concealed weapon.

"As a result he's been in hiding since probably last November," Greenbank said. Hagadone News reported that the whereabouts of Campbell and his family are unknown as of Monday.

See also:
Homeowners Return From Vacation, Find Car in Bedroom

Pray, Mont.: Buy the Whole Town for $1.4 Million

More on AOL Real Estate:
Find out how to
calculate mortgage payments.
homes for sale in your area.
foreclosures in your area.
Find rentals in your area.

What Does It Take to Be a Landlord

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

1 Comment

Filter by:
P. Finman

The version of this story that the AOL reporter received from Shane Greenbank is false, but it is not difficult to get at least part of the story accurate by reading between the lines. Sovereign citizens are completely cut off from the regular financial system because they follow no laws, pay no taxes, and acknowledge no legal identification. The most common all-cash illegal business sovereign citizens use to support themselves in Bonner County is drugs.

The sovereign citizen in this case had an outstanding warrant for his arrest and he was associated with a meth lab. Also, he had what his wife called a "divine drink that cures vertigo" (i.e. scopolamine) that can be made from a local weed. Scopolamine does cure vertigo in small doses, and in larger doses it is a date rape drug and hallucinogen. Law enforcement in Bonner County definitely knew about the arrest warrant, and they had to have known about the drugs. At best the county sheriff was lazy and/or afraid of the sovereign citizen and did absolutely nothing. At worst, the county sheriff was involved in and protecting the drug production.

Bonner County prosecutes land owners and ignores (and maybe protects) sovereign citizens. Bonner County is an absolutely beautiful area, but it is not safe to own property in Bonner County until law enforcement and the prosecutor's office are cleaned up.

October 04 2014 at 12:27 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply